Two enamel mugs of frothy hot chocolate beside a small saucepan, a wooden chocolate mill and a block of dark chocolate with a few fine shavings on a plain board.
Army cooks’ hot chocolate in two enamel mugs, with a saucepan, a wooden chocolate mill and shaved chocolate.

Army Cooks’ Chocolate, Half Milk and Half Water, from 1896

An ounce of scraped chocolate and an ounce of sugar thrown into a boiling pint of half milk, half water and milled for two or three minutes: the US Army cooks’ chocolate of 1896.

Recipe makes
About 2 cups, 2 mugs
Prep
Cook
Total

Army cooks’ hot chocolate in two enamel mugs, with a saucepan, a wooden chocolate mill and shaved chocolate.

The story behind the recipe

The US Army’s cooks were taught to make chocolate by the pint: an ounce of chocolate scraped fine, an ounce of sugar, and a pint “of perfectly boiling milk and water, of each one half,” milled and stirred for two or three minutes. The Manual for Army Cooks, printed by the Government Printing Office in 1896, put it just after the tea and added a warning: “Chocolate should never be made unless to be used immediately.”

Cakes, nibs and a mill

The manual explains its ingredient before the method. Chocolate, it says, “is produced chiefly from the seeds of the cocoa palm” (the cacao is a tree, not a palm) ground fine, mixed with sugar and pressed into thin cakes. Cocoa nibs, the broken seeds, “may be boiled, but they are not as soluble as the prepared chocolate.” To “mill” was to work the drink with a chocolate mill, a notched wooden stick spun between the palms to dissolve the chocolate and raise a froth.

The book allows one difference of opinion, “Some think that ten or twelve minutes’ boiling improves it,” and is firm about the other end: “If suffered to become cold or boiled again the flavor is injured.”

Read more about this recipe

The short route

We follow the manual’s own two or three minutes and take the pan off at the boil so the milk doesn’t rise over. The ounce weights stay; 2 tablespoons of sugar is close to an ounce. The manual’s chocolate was already “mixed with sugar” before the cook added more, so with a 70% bar and the added sugar the drink is lightly sweet and thin, half of it being water. A whisk does the work of the mill.

The Aztec cup, the Spanish pot and the Victorian cocoa tin are in A Short History of Hot Chocolate. A home cocoa of the same decade, also half milk and half water, is Breakfast Cocoa the 1886 Way.

Chocolate.

Chocolate is produced chiefly from the seeds of the cocoa palm ground to a fine powder, mixed with sugar, and reduced by great pressure to thin cakes.

Cocoa nibs are the seeds roughly broken, and may be boiled, but they are not as soluble as the prepared chocolate.

Scrape fine an ounce of chocolate and add an ounce of sugar; throw these into a pint of perfectly boiling milk and water, of each one half, and immediately mill and stir them well for two or three minutes until the chocolate and sugar are quite dissolved. Some think that ten or twelve minutes’ boiling improves it. Chocolate should never be made unless to be used immediately.

If suffered to become cold or boiled again the flavor is injured.

Manual for Army Cooks (1896), pp. 195–196

Read the full story

Ingredients

For About 2 cups, 2 mugs. Quantities are shown as written.

Quantities as written here, for About 2 cups, 2 mugs.

  • Dark chocolate, about 70% cacao28 g
  • Sugar2 tbsp
  • Whole milk1 cup
  • Water1 cup
Equipment
  • Fine grater
  • Small saucepan
  • Whisk
  • Mugs

Instructions

  1. Grate the dark chocolate finely and mix it with the sugar.

  2. Bring the whole milk and water to a boil in a small saucepan, watching that it doesn’t boil over, and take it off the heat.

  3. Tip in the chocolate and sugar at once and whisk briskly for 2 to 3 minutes, until smooth and frothy.

  4. Pour into mugs and serve straight away.

Nutrition

225calories per serving

Servings
2

Roughly estimated from USDA FoodData Central values for whole milk, 70% dark chocolate and granulated sugar, for one mug of two.

Recipe notes

When adjusting quantities

This is the manual’s pint. Double it for four mugs.

Notes

Quantities mentioned in these notes don’t change when you adjust the batch.

Changes from the source: a modern 70% dark chocolate for the Army’s sweetened cake chocolate, 2 tablespoons of sugar for the ounce, and a whisk for the mill. For the longer boil the manual mentions, keep the pan at a gentle simmer for 10 minutes, whisking now and then; it comes out a little thicker. A sweetened plain chocolate of 50 to 55% is closer to the 1890s cakes, and with it you can cut the sugar to 1 tablespoon.

Recipe details

Drink
Alcohol-free
Drink family
Hot Drinks
Region
American
Era
19th century
Source decade
1890s
Base
Tea, coffee & chocolateMilk & whey
Difficulty
Easy
Occasion
Dry January
Season
Winter