
Sinclair Lewis’s Repeal Punch, Brandy, Peach Brandy and Rum
Reader ratingsLemon juice and sugar, brandy, peach brandy and Jamaica rum, topped with sparkling water over a block of ice: the punch Sinclair Lewis sent to a Carmel contest on Repeal Day, 1933.
- Recipe makes
- About 9 1/2 cups, 15 punch cups
- Prep
- Total
Chill the spirits and the sparkling water first, and freeze the block of ice the day before. Add the sparkling water only when the guests arrive.
Repeal punch in a cut-glass bowl over a block of ice, with filled punch cups, a ladle and squeezed lemons.
The story behind the recipe
The novelist Sinclair Lewis sent this punch to a drinks contest in Carmel, California, as Prohibition ended: the juice of six lemons with sugar, brandy, peach brandy and Jamaica rum, lengthened with sparkling water and poured over a block of ice. A United Press story printed it on December 5, 1933, the day repeal took effect.
Three hundred recipes in Carmel
Carmel’s artist colony had collected “300 recipes for alcoholic drinks” for a contest “to determine the 20 best drinks in the world,” run by a body calling itself “the National Association for the Advancement of the Fine Art of Drinking.” Judging was set for the following Saturday. Lewis sent a punch. The writer Edgar Rice Burroughs sent an old-fashioned of bourbon, water, Angostura and simple syrup. Not every famous name took part: Eleanor Roosevelt wrote to the contest that “personally I am a dry.”
We haven’t found who won, so we don’t claim Lewis did. His recipe is a list of amounts with one instruction, to use a large punch bowl with a block of ice, and the steps below are ours. How the rest of the country spent that first legal night, mostly quietly, is in Old-Fashioneds at 35 Cents.
Read more about this recipe
Making it today
The amounts come from an American paper, so we read his pints as US pints, which turns them into neat cups: a cup of brandy and half a cup each of peach brandy and rum, with six cups of sparkling water. His half pound of powdered sugar is about a cup of superfine. With the spirits at 40%, the bowl comes to about 8% alcohol before the ice starts to melt, a little less as it does. Use a true peach brandy, distilled from peaches; a sweet peach liqueur is weaker and makes the bowl sweeter. By its parts it is a strong lemon punch, sharp and sweet, with the peach in the background. The paper prints no taste words.
For the same bowl without the spirits, make the Alcohol-Free Repeal Punch.
Original: About 9 1/2 cups, 15 punch cups
Ingredients
My drinksFor About 9 1/2 cups, 15 punch cups. Quantities are shown as written.
Quantities as written here, for About 9 1/2 cups, 15 punch cups.
- Lemons6
- Superfine sugar1 cup
- Brandy, chilled1 cup
- Peach brandy, chilled1/2 cup
- Jamaica rum, chilled1/2 cup
- Sparkling water, chilled6 cups
- Block of ice1
Measurement notes
Ingredients as written here
- 6 lemons
- 1 cup superfine sugar
- 1 cup brandy, chilled
- 1/2 cup peach brandy, chilled
- 1/2 cup Jamaica rum, chilled
- 6 cups sparkling water, chilled
- 1 block of ice
Equipment
Citrus juicer
Large punch bowl and ladle
Loaf pan, for the ice block
Long spoon
Instructions
Squeeze the juice from the lemons into a jug, then stir in the superfine sugar until it has dissolved.
Stir in the brandy, the peach brandy and the Jamaica rum.
Set the block of ice in a large punch bowl and pour the lemon and spirit mixture over it.
Just before serving, pour in the sparkling water and stir once, gently. Ladle into punch cups.
Nutrition
130calories per serving
- Servings
- 15
Estimated from typical values for 40% brandy and rum, lemon juice and sugar, for fifteen 5 fl oz punch cups; the sparkling water adds nothing.
Recipe notes
When adjusting quantities
Keep the brandy, peach brandy and rum at 2 to 1 to 1, and the sparkling water at three times the spirits, when you scale.
Notes
Quantities mentioned in these notes don’t change when you adjust the batch.
Lewis gives “the juice of six lemons,” which is about 1 1/8 cups, and “one half pound powdered sugar”; we use superfine sugar, the closest modern match, and dissolve it in the juice first, which his recipe doesn’t say. The fifteen 5 fl oz servings are our count.
The sums: 1 cup of brandy and 1 cup of rum and peach brandy together at 40% hold about 190 ml of alcohol, in about 2.3 liters with the lemon juice, sugar and water, or about 8%. Melting ice brings it toward 7%.
Freeze the ice block in a loaf pan the day before. A single large block melts more slowly than cubes, so the punch stays strong for longer.
Another punch from the dry years, built on tea and ginger ale, is the Ginger Ale Punch for a Dry Party.
Make ahead
Mix the lemon juice, sugar and spirits up to a few hours ahead and keep them cold. Pour them over the ice and add the sparkling water at the last minute.
Scaling changes the ingredients only; glassware, ice and timings need their own judgment. To adapt this recipe further, try the recipe tool at TuneMyRecipe (opens in a new tab), our sister site.
Sources and attribution
Sinclair Lewis’s punch, in Ronald Wagoner (United Press), “Recipes For Drink Pouring Into The Colony Of Artists,” Waterbury Evening Democrat (Waterbury, Conn.), December 5, 1933, pp. 1 and 7
See the original pages (scan at Library of Congress) (opens in a new tab)
Recipe details
- Drink family
- Punches & Cups
- Region
- American
- Source decade
- 1930s
- Difficulty
- Easy


