A plain glass bowl of clear amber-peach punch around one rectangular block of ice, beside a filled cup, an empty cup, a peach and whole and halved lemons by a window.
Alcohol-free repeal punch in a glass bowl over a block of ice, beside a peach and lemons.

Alcohol-Free Repeal Punch, with Tea and Peach Nectar

Sinclair Lewis’s 1933 repeal punch without the spirits: lemon juice and sugar with strong cold tea and peach nectar, topped with sparkling water over a block of ice.

Recipe makes
About 9 1/2 cups, 15 punch cups
Prep
Total

Includes 5 minutes for the tea to steep and about 25 minutes for it to cool. Freeze the block of ice the day before, and add the sparkling water only when the guests arrive.

Alcohol-free repeal punch in a glass bowl over a block of ice, beside a peach and lemons.

The story behind the recipe

This is Sinclair Lewis’s repeal punch of 1933 with its three spirits taken out: strong cold black tea in place of the brandy and rum, and peach nectar where the peach brandy went. The lemons, the sugar, the sparkling water and the block of ice are as he gave them to a drinks contest in Carmel, California, on the day Prohibition ended.

A dry guest on a wet night

Lewis left no alcohol-free version; this one is ours. The contest did hear from one dry correspondent. Eleanor Roosevelt wrote to it, as the United Press reported on December 5, 1933, that she could not enter a punch recipe, “but personally I am a dry.” Her husband’s proclamation that day asked Americans for “greater temperance throughout the Nation,” and the newspapers found that the first legal night was a quiet one, as told in Old-Fashioneds at 35 Cents.

Tea had carried punches without alcohol before. Bertha Stockbridge’s Ginger Ale Punch for a Dry Party of 1920 is weak tea with orange and lemon juice, sugar and ginger ale over a block of ice. Here a stronger tea gives the bowl body, and the nectar keeps a little of the peach.

Read more about this recipe

Making it today

Use a plain black tea and make it strong, four teaspoons to a cup and a half of water, because the sparkling water thins it a good deal. Let it cool completely before it meets the lemon juice, so the ice block lasts. A glass comes to about 70 calories, against about 130 for Lewis’s bowl. The tea keeps some caffeine, so for children or a late party a decaffeinated black tea works the same way.

Read the full story

Ingredients

For About 9 1/2 cups, 15 punch cups. Quantities are shown as written.

Quantities as written here, for About 9 1/2 cups, 15 punch cups.

  • Loose black tea4 tsp
  • Boiling water1 1/2 cups
  • Lemons6
  • Superfine sugar1 cup
  • Peach nectar, chilled1/2 cup
  • Sparkling water, chilled6 cups
  • Block of ice1
Equipment
  • Teapot or heatproof jug
  • Fine strainer
  • Citrus juicer
  • Large punch bowl and ladle
  • Loaf pan, for the ice block

Instructions

  1. Pour the boiling water over the loose black tea and leave it to steep for 5 minutes, then strain it and let it cool completely.

  2. Squeeze the juice from the lemons into a jug and stir in the superfine sugar until it has dissolved.

  3. Stir in the cold tea and the peach nectar.

  4. Set the block of ice in a large punch bowl and pour the mixture over it.

  5. Just before serving, pour in the sparkling water and stir once, gently. Ladle into punch cups.

Nutrition

70calories per serving

Servings
15

Estimated from typical values for sugar, lemon juice and peach nectar, for fifteen 5 fl oz punch cups; the tea and sparkling water add almost nothing.

Recipe notes

When adjusting quantities

Keep the tea at three times the peach nectar, and the sparkling water at three times the tea and nectar together, when you scale.

Notes

Quantities mentioned in these notes don’t change when you adjust the batch.

The changes from Lewis’s recipe are the swaps: a cup and a half of strong black tea for the cup of brandy and the half cup of Jamaica rum, and half a cup of peach nectar for the half cup of peach brandy. The lemons, sugar and sparkling water follow his amounts, read the same way as on the original page, and dissolving the sugar in the juice first is our step there too.

Peach nectars differ in sweetness; taste the bowl before you add the sparkling water, and add a little more lemon juice if it is too sweet.

Make ahead

Make the tea and mix it with the lemon juice, sugar and nectar up to a few hours ahead, and keep it in the fridge. Add the sparkling water at the last minute.

Recipe details

Drink
Alcohol-freeMocktail
Drink family
Punches & Cups
Region
American
Era
Prohibition era
Source decade
1930s
Base
Fruit & juiceTea, coffee & chocolate
Difficulty
Easy
Occasion
Dry January