Two tall glasses of pale pink sparkling punch over crushed ice beside a small glass jug of the same, a rosemary sprig and two curls of lemon peel on a shaded garden table.
Alcohol-free Garrick punch in two tall glasses and a jug, with rosemary and lemon peel.

Alcohol-Free Garrick Punch, Rosemary, Cherry and Soda

Lemon sugar, a cooled rosemary infusion and tart cherry juice, lengthened with soda and crushed ice: Terrington’s 1869 Gin Punch à la Garrick without the gin or the maraschino.

Recipe makes
About 900 ml, 4 glasses
Prep
Total

Includes about 30 minutes for the rosemary infusion to cool. Make it ahead and chill it to save time.

Alcohol-free Garrick punch in two tall glasses and a jug, with rosemary and lemon peel.

The story behind the recipe

This punch is new, built on the lines of William Terrington’s 1869 Gin Punch à la Garrick: lemon oil rubbed into sugar, a long pour of soda water and plenty of crushed ice. Where his bowl had half a pint of gin and a glass of maraschino, this one has a cooled rosemary infusion and tart cherry juice. No period alcohol-free version of the Garrick punch is known; the swaps are ours.

What stands in for gin

Gin’s main flavor is juniper and other dried herbs and spices, and no juice tastes like it. Rosemary is resinous and herbal, like juniper, and steeped in hot water it gives a clear, unsweetened liquid, so it fills the gin’s share of the bowl without adding sugar. Maraschino is a cherry liqueur, so tart cherry juice takes its small share. We use less sugar than the gin punch, because there is no spirit to balance; taste it before the soda goes in and add more if you like.

Terrington’s Cooling Cups and Dainty Drinks gave this punch only in its gin form. The method stays his: peel and sugar first, juice to dissolve them, then the rest, with soda and ice left to the last moment so it stays lively.

Read more about this recipe

Using it

It makes four tall glasses, about 900 ml. With labeled 0.0% juice and soda it contains no alcohol. The gin punch it comes from, and the book’s own words, are on Gin Punch à la Garrick, Lemon, Maraschino and Soda from 1869. How gin got from the licensed counter into the punch bowl is in Gin at the Counter, from the Gin Act to the Punch Bowl.

Read the full story

Ingredients

For About 900 ml, 4 glasses. Quantities are shown as written.

Quantities as written here, for About 900 ml, 4 glasses.

  • Boiling water250 ml
  • Small sprigs fresh rosemary2
  • Unwaxed lemon, for the peel1
  • Sugar30 g
  • Fresh lemon juice30 ml
  • Tart cherry juice, unsweetened60 ml
  • Chilled soda water400 ml
  • Crushed ice200 g
Equipment
  • Kettle
  • Heatproof jug
  • Vegetable peeler
  • Citrus juicer
  • Large jug or small punch bowl
  • 4 glasses

Instructions

  1. Pour the boiling water over the fresh rosemary in a heatproof jug and leave it for 5 minutes, then lift out the sprigs and let the infusion cool completely.

  2. Peel the unwaxed lemon thinly with a vegetable peeler, leaving the white pith behind.

  3. Put the peel in the large jug with the sugar and rub them together with the back of a spoon until the sugar is damp and smells strongly of lemon. Leave it for 10 minutes.

  4. Add the fresh lemon juice and stir until the sugar has dissolved, then lift out the peel.

  5. Stir in the cooled rosemary infusion and the tart cherry juice.

  6. Just before serving, pour in the chilled soda water and add the crushed ice. Stir once and pour into the glasses at once, with some ice in each.

Nutrition

40calories per serving

Servings
4

Roughly estimated per glass from USDA FoodData Central values for granulated sugar, tart cherry juice and lemon juice.

Recipe notes

When adjusting quantities

Keep about four parts rosemary infusion to one of cherry juice, and add the soda and ice only at the last moment.

Notes

Quantities mentioned in these notes don’t change when you adjust the batch.

Everything here except the method is ours: the rosemary infusion in place of gin, tart cherry juice in place of maraschino, and less sugar. Fresh rosemary is gentler than dried; use small sprigs, or the infusion turns bitter.

The infusion keeps, covered in the fridge, for a day. Make the lemon sugar and add the infusion and cherry juice up to an hour ahead, then add the soda and ice when you pour.

Recipe details

Drink
Alcohol-freeMocktail
Drink family
Punches & Cups
Region
British
Era
19th century
Source decade
1860s
Base
Fruit & juiceHerbs & flowers
Difficulty
Easy
Season
Summer